Free Shipping on Orders Over $79! - (607)458-5365
Buy Wholesale Cheese Online | Cheese Curds | Golden Age Cheese
Cheese Online

New York Extra Sharp Cheddar

Purchase this product now and earn 55 Points!
5.00 out of 5
(9 customer reviews)


Availability: In Stock


Product Description

Milk Type: Cow
Age: 2-3 Years
Texture: Semi-Hard
Suggested Wine Pairing: Cabernet Franc, Champagne, and Shiraz / Syrah
Suggested Beer Pairing: Belgian Ale and Pale Lager
Suggested Fruit Pairing: Apples, Grapes, and Pears
Suggested Meat Pairing: Roast Beef, Salami, and Summer Sausage

When assembling a cheese or a meat and cheese tray for your next wine tasting party, be sure to include extra sharp cheddar among your offerings. Quite unlike any other cheese you will be serving, extra sharp cheddar brings its own rich, pungent taste that is best offset by a full red wine. Serve it with crackers or simply by itself. Melt it onto tiny crusty pieces of bread in the broiler and top with chives, scallions, or cilantro for delicious hors d’oeuvres.

Additional Information

Weight 1.00 lbs

9 reviews for New York Extra Sharp Cheddar

  1. Holly W
    5 out of 5


    If you’re looking for the perfect combo of creamy and sharp–this is it. It makes a deliciously creamy mac and cheese–not as bold as Jurrasic.

    A small amount on a salad goes a long way–making it a healthy indulgence.

  2. Ledbel
    5 out of 5


    My favorite extra sharp cheddar, hard to stay away from. Some times we just eat pieces of it with nothing else, it’s that good.

  3. Kiran777
    5 out of 5



  4. sindee45
    5 out of 5


    I love extra sharp just for the snackin’. I would live on this cheese!! It brings a smile to my face!!!

  5. donna0600
    5 out of 5


    This cheese is incredible! I use this in recipes or just as a snack and my family loves it!

  6. kglight
    5 out of 5


    I tried some of this at a party and fell in love. I am a cheddar snob and especially love the New York extra sharp. Keeps my taste buds dancing!

  7. trumpthis59
    5 out of 5


    I recently received a lb of this cheese as a gift after having a conversation about the best extra sharp cheddars. I was told that your NY extra sharp was the best, and now I know it!

  8. Carol32608
    5 out of 5


    This cheese is AMAZING! Aged to perfection. So delicious. I use it in lots of my meals

  9. Nylsa
    5 out of 5


    This cheese vanishes quickly from my fridge. Our favorite thing to make with it is macaroni and cheese, but it also grates well for tacos/casserole toppings and we are constantly nibbling on chunks of it for a snack as well!

Add a review

Related Items

More Similar Items